These guidelines should be read in conjunction with the relevant Module Outlines, in Section 3. They are used and interpreted by markers in relation to the relevant level of study and the Learning Outcomes for the module.
Students should study these carefully as – in combination with each module’s learning outcomes – they give a clear indication of the kind of qualities examiners, while exercising their professional judgement, will be guided by when assessing your work.
Principal Study: Performance |
Principal Study: Techniques – Instrumental and Vocal |
Principal Study: Composition |
Principal Study: Techniques – Composition |
Audition |
Composition and Arranging (options and electives) |
Conducting |
Continuous Assessment |
Creative Project |
Ensemble Performance |
Ensemble Preparation |
Presentations |
Professional Placement |
Reflective Portfolio |
Solo Performance (options and electives) |
Theory and Musicianship |
Tutor Report |
Viva Voce |
Written assignments |
Marking Guidelines: Principal Study: Performance
% Mark | Descriptor | |
I (high) | 90-100 | Exceptional: Virtuosic playing/singing; exceptional maturity of conception; performances demonstrate complete physical, emotional, musical and intellectual mastery; thought-provoking and memorable. |
I (mid) | 80-89 | Outstanding: Outstanding technical command; interpretations with individuality, depth and flair; outstanding stagecraft, communication and (as appropriate) ensemble; performances that are challenging, imaginative, or in other ways notably accomplished, demonstrating mature musicianship. |
I (low) | 70-79 | Excellent: Technically fluent, with a control that adds an exciting element to the performance; stylish and individual performing with a degree of authority, imagination and flair; excellent presentation, audience rapport and (as appropriate) ensemble. |
II i | 60-69 | Very good: Very good technique and (as appropriate) ensemble with rare problems; consistent interpretations which demonstrate an awareness of structure, form and stylistic conventions; a real commitment in the music-making is conveyed to the listener. |
II ii | 50-59 | Good: Sound technique, which can comfortably cope with most demands of the repertoire; consistent, if not always stylish playing, which is generally well shaped; good presentation and (as appropriate) ensemble with a sense of involvement in the music-making. |
III | 40-49 | Adequate: A basically secure technique is displayed, in spite of some aberrations; coherent interpretations if somewhat lacking in sensitivity to issues of style; satisfactory projection, (as appropriate) ensemble, and rapport with the audience. |
Fail | 30-39 | Some merits: Some technical merits, but the performance also reveals significant deficiencies of technique and (as appropriate) ensemble; patchy interpretations with little understanding of appropriate style; limited skills in presentation and projection. |
Fail (low) | 20-29 | Few merits: Numerous or serious deficiencies in technique lead to faltering and uncomfortable performances; mechanical and inconsistent interpretations; little understanding of, or ability to project, appropriate presentational skills. |
Fail (lowest) | 0-19 | Severely limited: Major technical deficiencies result in tentative and hesitant performances; no consistent sense of style is conveyed; an inability to understand and communicate elementary presentational skills. |
Marking Guidelines: Principal Study: Techniques – Instrumental & Vocal
Class | % Mark | Descriptor |
I (high) | 90-100 | Exceptional: Virtuosic and effortless technical command; exceptional control revealed in performances demonstrating complete technical mastery; an exceptional level of (as appropriate to Principal Study) stylistic awareness, projection, language skills and technical understanding. |
I (mid) | 80-89 | Outstanding: Outstanding technical command which is fluent and error-free; playing that communicates energy and panache. Tone production, range, diction, intonation, breath control, stamina, etc. (as appropriate to Principal Study) developed to a sophisticated level; an outstanding level of (as appropriate to Principal Study) stylistic awareness, projection, language skills and technical understanding. |
I (low) | 70-79 | Excellent: A high level of technical assurance and accuracy; playing that communicates surety and some flair; excellent standard of tone production, range, diction, intonation, breath control, stamina etc. (as appropriate to Principal Study) with infrequent or inconsequential blemishes; excellent level of (as appropriate to Principal Study) stylistic awareness, projection, language skills and technical understanding. |
II I | 60-69 | Very good: Very good technical control and level of accuracy; some physical ease; tone production, range, diction, breath control, stamina etc. (as appropriate to Principal Study) developed to a high level with rare, minor lapses; a convincing level of (as appropriate to Principal Study) stylistic awareness, projection, language skills and technical understanding. |
II ii | 50-59 | Good: Sound overall technical control; a good overall level of accuracy despite occasional, notable lapses; tone production, range, diction, intonation, breath control, stamina etc. (as appropriate to Principal Study) developed enough to cope with most technical demands at this level; largely convincing level of (as appropriate to Principal Study) stylistic awareness, projection, language skills and technical understanding. |
III | 40-49 | Adequate: A basically secure level of technical control; broadly convincing level of accuracy despite some significant lapses; tone production, range, posture, diction, intonation, breath control, stamina etc. (as appropriate to Principal Study) sufficiently well developed to cope with majority of technical demands at this level; somewhat convincing level of (as appropriate to Principal Study) stylistic awareness, projection, language skills and technical understanding. |
Fail | 30-39 | Some merits: Certain technical merits, but also some significant deficiencies in accuracy and continuity. Tone production, range, diction, intonation, breath control, stamina (as appropriate to Principal Study) insufficiently developed or insecure; inconsistent or unconvincing level of (as appropriate to Principal Study) stylistic awareness, projection, language skills and technical understanding. |
Fail (low) | 20-29 | Few merits: Very significant deficiencies in technique, accuracy, continuity; tone production, range, diction, intonation, breath control, stamina etc. (as appropriate to Principal Study) far from acceptable; little evidence of (as appropriate to Principal Study) stylistic awareness, projection, language skills and technical understanding. |
Fail (lowest) | 0-19 | Severely limited: Major technical deficiencies; no fluency evident; tone production, range, diction, intonation, breath control, stamina etc. (as appropriate to Principal Study) unreliable and under-developed; technical deficiencies too severe to allow for demonstration of (as appropriate to Principal Study) stylistic awareness, projection, language skills and technical understanding. |
Marking Guidelines: Principal Study: Composition
Class | % Mark | Descriptor | ||
TECHNIQUE | INVENTION | PROFESSIONALISM | ||
I (high) | 90-100 | Exceptional, highly compelling, and sophisticated control of structure, materials, and forces. | Exceptional, highly compelling, and imaginative work demonstrating a sophisticated aesthetic sensibility and communicating subtle and individual musical intent with clarity. | Exceptional awareness and upholding of professional standards of presentation and notation, communicating the composer’s intentions with sophistication, clarity and elegance. |
I (mid) | 80-89 | Outstanding, compelling, and sophisticated control of structure, materials, and forces. | Outstanding, compelling, and imaginative work projecting a coherent aesthetic sensibility and communicating subtle musical intent with clarity. | Outstanding awareness and upholding of professional standards of presentation and notation, communicating the composer’s intentions with sophistication and clarity. |
I (low) | 70-79 | Excellent and highly impressive control of structure, materials, and forces. | Excellent and highly imaginative work projecting generally coherent aesthetic aims and generally communicating musical intent with clarity. | Excellent awareness and upholding of professional standards of presentation and notation, communicating the composers with sophistication and fluency. |
II i | 60-69 | Very good and generally convincing control of structure, materials, and forces. | Very good and consistently imaginative work projecting generally coherent aesthetic aims and generally communicating musical intent with clarity. | Very good awareness and upholding of professional standards of presentation and notation, communicating the composer’s intentions with detail and accuracy. |
II ii | 50-59 | Good with satisfactory control of structure, materials, and forces. | Good work demonstrating some imagination and some ability of project aesthetic aims communicating musical intent with some degree of clarity. | Good awareness and satisfactory upholding of professional standards of presentation and notation, but with some inaccuracies and errors. |
III | 40-49 | Adequate, recognisable but limited control of structure, material, and forces. | Adequate work demonstrating limited but acceptable evidence of imaginative engagement and basic aesthetic awareness communicating musical intent with a limited degree of clarity. | Adequate with a generally unreliable level of awareness of professional standards of presentation and notation, with consistent inaccuracies and errors. |
Fail | 30-39 | Some merits with a generally unreliable level of control of structure, materials, and forces. | Some merits with a generally unreliable degree of imaginative engagement and little or no aesthetic awareness; musical intent is not communicated clearly. | Some merits with a generally unreliable level of awareness of professional standards of presentation and notation, with inadequate standards of notation. |
Fail (low) | 20-29 | Few merits with an unsatisfactory level of control of structure, materials, and forces. | Few merits with an unreliable degree of imaginative engagement; musical intent is not communicated clearly. | Few merits with an unsatisfactory level of awareness of professional standards of presentation and notation, with inadequate standards of notation. |
Fail (lowest) | 0-19 | Severely limited with little or no control of structure, materials, and forces. | Severely limited with little or no evidence of imaginative engagement or communication of musical intent. | Severely limited with little or no evidence of awareness of professional standards of presentation and notation. |
Marking Guidelines: Principal Study: Techniques – Composition
Class | % Mark | Descriptor |
I (high) | 90-100 | Exceptional engagement with the exercises delivered with technical sensitivity and fluency, clarity of intent, imaginative flare, and demonstrating a comprehensive understanding of the exercises’ context. Immaculately presented. |
I (mid) | 80-89 | Outstanding engagement with the exercises delivered with technical sensitivity and fluency, clarity of intent, imaginative flare, and demonstrating considerable understanding of the exercises’ context. Extremely high standards of presentation. |
I (low) | 70-79 | Excellent engagement with the exercises delivered with technical fluency, satisfactory clarity of intent and imagination, and demonstrating some understanding of the exercises’ context. Excellent, if not faultless, presentation. |
II i | 60-69 | Very good engagement with the exercises delivered with technical fluency, satisfactory clarity of intent and imagination, and demonstrating some understanding of the exercises’ context. Very good general level of presentation. |
II ii | 50-59 | Good engagement with the exercises delivered with some technical fluency, satisfactory clarity of intent and imagination, and demonstrating limited understanding of the exercises’ context. Mainly good general level of presentation. |
III | 40-49 | Adequate engagement with the exercises delivered with limited but satisfactory technical fluency, clarity of intent, and some evidence of imagination and understanding of the exercises’ context. Adequate presentation potentially lacking in some areas. |
Fail | 30-39 | Some merits although generally limited engagement with the exercise delivered with some examples of technical fluency, clarity of intent, and little evidence of imagination or an understanding of the exercises’ context. Presentation may be lacking. |
Fail (low) | 20-29 | Few merits demonstrating limited engagement with or understanding of the exercises, little evidence of technical fluency, clarity of intent, or imagination, and little or no understanding of the exercises’ context. Presentation may be a barrier to reading the music. |
Fail (lowest) | 0-19 | Severely limited demonstration little or no engagement with or understanding of the exercise, technical fluency, clarity of intent, imagination, and understanding of the exercises’ context. Presentation may be very poor. |
Marking Guidelines: Audition
Class | % Mark | Descriptor |
I (high) | 90-100 | Exceptional: Virtuosic command over technical demands of the audition repertoire; exceptional accuracy, musicality and awareness of context demonstrated in orchestral excerpts and sight-reading; test pieces with exceptional musicality, control and impressive projection. |
I (mid) | 80-89 | Outstanding: A highly impressive audition with fluent and imaginative performing in all disciplines; sight-reading is assured and accurate with an impressive degree of detail conveyed to the listener; instinctively musical; test pieces of outstanding musical and technical level. |
I (low) | 70-79 | Excellent: An excellent technique is displayed, and the demands of the audition repertoire are impressively overcome; musical, intelligent and informed performing with a pleasing sense of style; sight reading is fluent and generally very perceptive; test pieces portray excellent and highly convincing musicality and imagination. |
II i | 60-69 | Very good: Technically very able and the demands of the audition are mostly very well addressed; though the sight reading tests may well have a lack of detail in some respects, overall there is good deal of coherence and musicality; test pieces are very well prepared and convincingly presented. |
II ii | 50-59 | Good: Technically sound if sometimes a little inconsistent; sight reading has good shape, if lacking detail at times and with some error; some sense of context and musical style is portrayed; test pieces are mostly well prepared, on the whole musically convincing and coherent if never particularly inspiring. |
III | 40-49 | Adequate: Reasonably coherent if sometimes faltering performances of the audition repertoire; sight reading that may have some degree of continuity though lacking detail and a sense of context; test repertoire is reasonably competent, though often unimaginative and lacking character |
Fail | 30-39 | Some merits: Although there are elements of the audition that may be satisfactory, in totality it is wanting; there may be repetitious weakness and stumbles in sight reading; poor understanding of the context and requirements of excerpts; test pieces may be somewhat lacking in musical judgement and technical fluency. |
Fail (low) | 20-29 | Few merits: Problems exist in most of, or the entire audition repertoire; sight reading is weak, with nuance and detail lost in a bid to complete the exercise; poor or no sense of context; test pieces display technical weaknesses, poor preparation and immature musical judgements. |
Fail (lowest) | 0-19 | Severely limited: Stumbling and rife with error; very poorly prepared test pieces; sight-reading incoherent and with constant breakdowns; mechanical at best; disjointed and inconsistent throughout. |
Marking Guidelines: Composition and Arranging (options and electives)
Class | % Mark | Descriptor |
I (high) | 90-100 | Exceptional: Profound and individual compositions which marry an exceptional and expressive voice with a consummate technical facility; an originality of expression that pervades the entire portfolio; virtuosic technical control over the chosen medium; immaculately presented. Arrangements showing technical mastery and a profound knowledge of instruments and their combinations, presented to an exceptional professional level and displaying exceptional resourcefulness and imagination. |
I (mid) | 80-89 | Outstanding: Original compositions containing a uniformly high level of creativity and technical surety; the best of the portfolio has a profound expressive import and a virtuosic technical control over the chosen medium; extremely high standards of presentation. Arrangements showing high skill, creativity, and imagination, professionally presented. |
I (low) | 70-79 | Excellent: Vital and mostly original work; powerful and imaginative ideas in compositions which demonstrate an excellent exploration of the chosen medium; excellent technical control over structure and instrumentation, within the context of works which show enterprise; a clear compositional ‘voice’ is apparent; excellent presentation. Arrangements showing excellent judgement of instrument choice, voicing and balance, presented with care and attention to details of expression. |
II i | 60-69 | Very good: A portfolio with passages of real flair and imagination; strong ideas on the whole and, for the most part, a successfully accomplished spirit of adventure; very good technical control through secure management of performing forces, within the context of work that presents an appropriate degree of compositional challenge; a developing compositional ‘voice’ is apparent; very good, if not faultless, presentation. Arrangements generally appropriate to the instruments chosen, well presented and practicable in performance |
II ii | 50-59 | Good: Competent portfolio with moments of originality; not always of consistent quality the portfolio may contain safe work that takes few risks, or adventurous work that fails to come off; solid compositional technique but lacking flair; secure understanding of formal and structural control over sustained durations; good general level of presentation. Arrangements made with some sense of appropriate style and instrumentation, well presented though sometimes lacking in detail. |
III | 40-49 | Adequate: Basic consistency across the portfolio; compositions that may be a mixture of external influences and some embryonic compositional experiments; a technique that provides some basis for artistic invention, even if the portfolio includes some obvious misjudgements and unidiomatic writing; some moments of individuality and originality; adequate presentation. Arrangements generally workable and consistent but often showing unimaginative choices and errors of judgement. |
Fail | 30-39 | Some merits: Although the portfolio has interesting moments there is an inconsistency and often a dullness about the music; derivative and rather lacking in imagination; notes are ‘worked’ on the page with little understanding of their effect in performance; technical insecurities are too numerous; presentation may be somewhat lacking. Portfolio may be of insufficient length, or fail to follow the prescribed guidelines. Arrangements may contain errors of balancing or instrumental ranges, displaying only a patchy knowledge of good voicings and sometimes scrappy presentation. |
Fail (low) | 20-29 | Few merits: A portfolio which contains very little imaginative composition; inconsistent both in terms of the music’s expressive import and in technical competence; many errors; presentation may be sloppy. Portfolio may be of insufficient length, or fail to follow the prescribed guidelines. Arrangements that are incomplete or too short, presented without care and attention, with notational errors. |
Fail (lowest) | 0-19 | Severely limited: Bland and unimaginative composition with a multitude of technical errors; little understanding of idiomatic writing; very poor ability to sustain ideas over appropriate durations; presentation may be very poor. Portfolio may be of insufficient length, or fail to follow the prescribed guidelines. Arrangements fail to show basic competence in notation, poorly presented and incomplete. |
Marking Guidelines: Conducting
Class | % Mark | Descriptor |
I (high) | 90-100 | Exceptional: Virtuosic conducting, showing complete technical control, exceptional maturity of conception, sensitive and intellectually charged music-making, intuitive and insightful, memorable and thought-provoking. The conductor conveys exceptional commitment, control and intensity, with compelling, exciting and consummately professional presentation. |
I (mid) | 80-89 | Outstanding: Outstanding technical command; technique always in service of interpretation, showing interpretative individuality, abundant intellectual depth, intuitive, with outstanding flair and panache. Risk-taking, provocative, challenging or otherwise notably accomplished performances, entirely focused and controlled. |
I (low) | 70-79 | Excellent: Always fluent, with a quality of technical control that adds an exciting element to the performance. Performance with imagination, style and individuality willing to take risks, creative, thoughtful and showing flair, with excellent presentation and audience rapport. |
II i | 60-69 | Very good: Very good technical control; with rare signs of technical insecurity that do not detract from the interpretation. Interpretations are highly effective, demonstrating an awareness of structure, form and appropriate stylistic conventions. |
II ii | 50-59 | Good: Sound technique displayed, which can comfortably cope with the demands of the repertoire. Playing is generally well-shaped and consistent, though not always stylish. A generally well-projected sense of involvement in the music making. |
III | 40-49 | Adequate: An essentially secure technique in spite of some aberrations, able to match demands of repertoire chosen, showing an acceptable understanding of stylistic features of the repertoire, if at times lacking sensitivity, maturity or refinement. Some evidence of commitment and projection of character, showing a generally satisfactory audience rapport. |
Fail | 30-39 | Some merits: Certain technical merits but the performance reveals some technical deficiencies. Interpretations are patchy, with little understanding of appropriate style, presentation is generally awkward and uncomfortable, and projection limited. |
Fail (low) | 20-29 | Few merits: Significant deficiencies in technique lead to faltering and uncomfortable performances. Interpretations can be mechanical and inconsistent, with poor musicality, lacking in subtlety and stylistic awareness. Little understanding shown of how to project or present a performance. |
Fail (lowest) | 0-19 | Severely limited: Major technical deficiencies result in tentative and hesitant performances which show no consistent sense of style, and a total lack of musical sensitivity. There is an inability to understand and communicate the most elementary presentational skills. |
Marking Guidelines: Continuous Assessment
Class | % Mark | Descriptor |
I (high) | 90-100 | Exceptional: An exceptional engagement with, and contribution to the course; the highest level of commitment is evident resulting in significant development in the activity; exceptionally high levels of attainment pertinent to the discipline building upon a very high level of aptitude. Exceptionally developed understanding of participation and working with others in chamber/ensemble performance. |
I (mid) | 80-89 | Outstanding: An outstanding engagement with, and contribution to the course; evidence of thoughtful reflection and self-motivation which results in very high level of personal development; outstanding levels of attainment pertinent to the discipline building upon a high level of aptitude. Very highly developed understanding of participation and working with others in chamber/ensemble performance. |
I (low) | 70-79 | Excellent: An excellent and always committed and discriminating approach to study is evident; significant developments as a consequence of a balanced, mature and critical assessment of needs and limitations; an excellent overall standard is attained in the discipline. Highly developed understanding of participation and working with others in chamber/ensemble performance. |
II i | 60-69 | Very good: A committed and dedicated approach is evident; very good level of development building upon some degree of natural aptitude in the discipline; overall very good standards are achieved. Well-developed understanding of participation and working with others in chamber/ensemble performance. |
II ii | 50-59 | Good: A generally good engagement with, and contribution to the course; good level of development and consistent performance in the activity; good level of attainment in the discipline. Good understanding of participation and working with others in chamber/ensemble performance. |
III | 40-49 | Adequate: An acceptable contribution to the course and engagement with the course activities; the approach is not always consistent and there may be lack of focus and dedication; adequate standards are achieved. Some understanding of participation and working with others in chamber/ensemble performance. |
Fail | 30-39 | Some merits: Patchy commitment and performance; the personal development of the student in the discipline is uneven; ultimately, whilst there may be some outputs that are acceptable, outcomes are generally rough and ready. Little demonstrable understanding of participation and working with others in chamber/ensemble performance. |
Fail (low) | 20-29 | Few merits: Poor engagement with course activities; poor and immature management of individual learning resulting in a low level of attainment. Poor understanding of participation and working with others in chamber/ensemble performance. |
Fail (lowest) | 0-19 | Severely limited: Very poor engagement with the course, which might be manifest in poor attendance and commitment; development is very limited; ultimately very poor standards are attained. Lack of understanding of participation and working with others in chamber/ensemble performance. |
Marking Guidelines: Creative Project
Class | % Mark | Descriptor |
I (high) | 90-100 | Exceptional: An exceptional ability to organise, reflect upon and convey a wide range of high quality learning experiences and representative materials; promotional materials of a highly professional standard, expertly presented; a very mature and extremely well balanced approach is evident throughout; submission is the best reflection of the outstanding attributes of the individual; submission reflects authoritative engagement with relevant technologies and media (where appropriate) and a highly developed understanding of their audiences. Project proposal is exceptionally creative, imaginative, original and achievable. |
I (mid) | 80-89 | Outstanding: An extremely strong submission which is meticulously prepared and demonstrates a wealth of high quality learning and a well-judged range of outstanding representative materials; a mature reflection with admirably concision and intellectual acumen; a very good professional presentation of promotional materials, underpinned by an outstanding range of learning experiences; submission reflects accomplished engagement with relevant technologies and media (where appropriate) and a developed understanding of their audiences. Project proposal is highly creative, imaginative, ambitious and achievable |
I (low) | 70-79 | Excellent: A concise, thoughtful, insightful and balanced summary of excellent learning experiences and a range of excellent representative materials; sophisticated and articulate reflection which is balanced and informative; promotional materials of an acceptable professional standard, conveying the excellent level of expertise of the individual; submission reflects a high standard of engagement with relevant technologies and media (where appropriate) and a sound understanding of their audiences. Project proposal is creative, conveys excellent initiative, and is achievable. |
II i | 60-69 | Very good: A very good overall account of a broad range of learning experiences; materials are generally succinct and punchy; an evident an ability to prioritise, select and reject material; a very worthy reflective account, well thought through and engaging; promotional materials are of a very good standard, imaginatively prepared; submission reflects consistent engagement with relevant technologies and media (where appropriate) and an understanding of their audiences. Project proposal demonstrates some creativity, very good initiative, and its aims are achievable, albeit with some renewed attention to planning. |
II ii | 50-59 | Good: Reasonably detailed accounting of the activities undertaken and a reasonable selection of representative materials; a clear sense of the learning experience of the individual is evident; good, if perhaps somewhat unsophisticated evaluation which may be characterized by some naïve solecisms; a reasonable range of good experience is evident though the reflection; promotional materials carefully prepared if somewhat uninspiring; submission reflects some engagement, if inconsistent, with relevant technologies and media (where appropriate) and developing understanding of their audiences. Project proposal is somewhat creative, and shows a degree of initiative. Its aims are achievable with some renewed attention to planning and detail. |
III | 40-49 | Adequate: An acceptable record of learning experiences undertaken and adequate representative materials; some ability to reflect upon and evaluate these experiences objectively; perhaps a somewhat ramshackle and disorganised presentation although it reveals a generally good range of activity; promotional materials acceptable if a little unfocussed; submission reflects basic engagement with relevant technologies and media (where appropriate) and a limited understanding of their audiences. Project proposal reveals basic creativity, and the potential to be imaginative. Its aims are achievable with significant renewed attention to planning and detail. |
Fail | 30-39 | Some merits: Although there may be some evidence of learning activity the materials lack focus and do not demonstrate any consistency; perhaps characterized by a mechanistic, unfocussed and essentially uncritical listing of learning which may seem rather insubstantial; promotional materials rather weak, with infelicities and inaccuracies; submission reflects limited engagement with relevant technologies and media, where appropriate, and lacks some understanding of their audiences. Project proposal lacks sufficient creativity and imagination, and its aims are unclear and not achievable without considerable renewed attention to planning, detail and scope. |
Fail (low) | 20-29 | Few merits: Very limited evidence of learning experiences and insubstantial representative materials; poorly organised and lacking any critical and evaluative skill; little more than a listing of what is probably a rather dubious and slight range of experience; promotional materials unacceptable and careless; submission reflects significantly limited engagement with relevant technologies and media and underdeveloped understanding of their audiences. Project proposal lacks creativity and imagination, and attention to detail. Its aims are poorly identified and unachievable without comprehensive renewed attention to planning, detail and scope. |
Fail (lowest) | 0-19 | Severely limited: Messy and disorganised; it is unclear from the presented materials the essence of the learning that has taken place; lacking any focus and detail; little or no ability to reflect upon the developmental processes of learning; promotional materials always poorly presented; submission reflects severely limited engagement with relevant technologies and media and little or no understanding of their audience. Project proposal is flimsy and uncreative. It fails to identify realistic and achievable aims and scope, and is untenable without wholesale review. |
Marking Guidelines: Ensemble Performance
Class | % Mark | Descriptor |
I (high) | 90-100 | Exceptional: Virtuosic playing, showing complete technical control, exceptional maturity of conception, sensitive and intellectually charged playing, always intuitive and insightful, revelatory and thought-provoking. The player conveys exceptional commitment and intensity, with compelling, exciting and consummately professional presentation. The performer’s contribution to the ensemble is inspirational, with charismatic and exceptional musical leadership skills, matched by a mature and penetrating musical personality and ensemble sensitivity. The model team player who has abundant aural ability manifest in exemplary performer awareness and responsiveness. |
I (mid) | 80-89 | Outstanding: Outstanding technical command; technique always in service of interpretation, showing interpretative individuality, abundant intellectual depth, intuitive, with outstanding flair and panache. Risk-taking, provocative and challenging performances., entirely focused and controlled. The performer will be an authoritative and dynamic ensemble player, showing outstanding technical and musical attributes that charge and enrich the ensemble. |
I (low) | 70-79 | Excellent: Always fluent, with a quality of technical control that adds an exciting element to the performance. Performance with imagination, style and individuality willing to take risks, creative, thoughtful and showing flair, with excellent presentation and audience rapport. The performer is an excellent and animated team player, spontaneous and musically responsive to colleagues. |
II i | 60-69 | Very good: Very good technical control; with rare signs of technical insecurity that do not detract from the interpretation. Interpretations are highly effective, demonstrating an awareness of structure, form and appropriate stylistic conventions. Ensemble playing is coherent and balanced, projecting a real sense of commitment to the audience. Reliable and well prepared, showing flexibility and responsiveness in ensemble. |
II ii | 50-59 | Good: Sound technique displayed, which can comfortably cope with the demands of the repertoire. Playing is generally well-shaped and consistent, though not always stylish. A generally well-projected sense of involvement in the music making, showing some flexibility and imagination in ensemble, and a generally strong focus. |
III | 40-49 | Adequate: An essentially secure technique in spite of some aberrations, able to match demands of repertoire chosen, showing an acceptable understanding of stylistic features of the repertoire, if at times lacking sensitivity, maturity or refinement. Some evidence of commitment and projection of character, showing a generally satisfactory audience rapport. Some consistency of approach shown, though limited in the degree of intellectual or musical stimulation to the ensemble. |
Fail | 30-39 | Some merits: Certain technical merits but the performance reveals some technical deficiencies. Interpretations are patchy, with little understanding of appropriate style, presentation is generally awkward and uncomfortable, and projection limited. The individual performer may be a hindrance to the ensemble, lacking in commitment, flexibility and musical awareness |
Fail (low) | 20-29 | Few merits: Significant deficiencies in technique lead to faltering and uncomfortable performances. Interpretations can be mechanical and inconsistent, with poor musicality both individually and as part of the ensemble, lacking in subtlety and stylistic awareness. Little understanding shown of how to project or present a performance, poor technique and preparation making the performer a major hindrance to the ensemble. |
Fail (lowest) | 0-19 | Severely limited: Major technical deficiencies result in tentative and hesitant performances which show no consistent sense of style, and a total lack of musical sensitivity. There is an inability to understand and communicate the most elementary presentational skills, and there is little evidence of engagement with the ensemble, of communication or of focus, |
Marking Guidelines: Ensemble Preparation
Class | % Mark | Descriptor |
I (high) | 90-100 | Exceptional: The performer’s contribution to the ensemble is inspirational, with charismatic and exceptional musical leadership skills, matched by a mature and penetrating musical personality and ensemble sensitivity. Faultless pre-rehearsal preparation. The model team player who has abundant aural ability manifest in exemplary performer awareness and responsiveness. |
I (mid) | 80-89 | Outstanding: An authoritative and dynamic ensemble performer, who shows outstanding resourcefulness in rehearsals, helping to find solutions to challenging musical problems. A keenly intellectual and intuitive musician, who displays outstanding technical and musical attributes that charge and enrich the ensemble. Highly efficient and productive in rehearsal situation. |
I (low) | 70-79 | Excellent: Excellent and animated team player. Rehearsal contributions underpinned by thorough knowledge of individual part and keen awareness of the player’s ensemble role and function. Spontaneous and musically responsive to colleagues in whatever performance context. Technically assured. |
II i | 60-69 | Very good: Imaginative playing in rehearsal; committed and focused; entirely reliable and well prepared; responsive and willing; flexible and able to adapt the performing within context of ensemble; technically very sound; able to respond well to new ideas. |
II ii | 50-59 | Good: Very reliable performing in rehearsal; keen to work hard and efficiently to secure good results from the ensemble; receptive to ideas; at times able to put forward creative solutions to performance challenges; some imagination; generally well-focused in rehearsal. |
III | 40-49 | Adequate: A competent, if somewhat uninspiring contribution to the ensemble’s preparations. The performer is generally reliable but there is rarely any dynamism and energy. An adequate focus on the job to hand and some sense of working efficiently. A reasonably consistent role is played, though there may be little in the way of intellectual or musical stimulation to the ensemble. |
Fail | 30-39 | Some merits: May be something of a hindrance to the ensemble through poor technical competence and/or preparation. Something of a passenger, who at times seems disembodied from the ensemble, lacking commitment and musical awareness. Rather inflexible. |
Fail (low) | 20-29 | Few merits: A major hindrance to the ensemble. Weak technical ability and poor preparation. Unreliable. Lacking sensitivity and aural awareness. Very inflexible. Lacking focus. |
Fail (lowest) | 0-19 | Severely limited: The performer is little engaged with the activity of the ensemble either musically or organisationally. Very poor musical contributions in rehearsals may be matched with patchy and tardy attendance. Uncommunicative. Totally devoid of focus. |
Marking Guidelines: Presentations
Class | % Mark | Descriptor |
I (high) | 90-100 | Exceptional: An exceptional ability to communicate sophisticated arguments revealing insight with authority and enthusiasm; content of maturity, confidence and weight; notably wide-ranging evidence, research, sources and materials of exceptional quality. |
I (mid) | 80-89 | Outstanding: An outstandingly well-communicated presentation of insightful and original arguments; content of considerable maturity; draws on a substantial range of well-chosen source materials, research, and evidence of a consistently high quality. |
I (low) | 70-79 | Excellent: Engaging and thought-provoking, presented with confidence, authority and some originality; thorough selection and utilisation of source materials; an excellent attempt to demonstrate issues through pertinent research and accompanying materials. |
II i | 60-69 | Very good: Well-researched, diligently prepared presentation of a well-constructed argument; demonstrates a convincing balance of evidence and subjective option; illustration of points draws on a range of sources and materials of very good quality. |
II ii | 50-59 | Good: A fairly well researched and, for the most part, carefully prepared presentation; demonstrates a solid level of understanding, sustaining its argument despite some weaknesses; employs appropriate sources and useful accompanying materials. |
III | 40-49 | Adequate: An acceptably researched and prepared presentation, demonstrating some ability to sustain an overall argument despite significant errors, weaker passages, and limited employment of useful or high-quality sources, research, and evidence. |
Fail | 30-39 | Some merit: Inconsistent presentation with incoherent argument; some attempt to engage with source materials and evidence, but containing very significant errors or weaknesses; attempts to demonstrate issues are mostly ineffective; accompanying materials of little relevance or low quality. |
Fail (low) | 20-29 | Few merits: Poor presentation revealing sloppy preparation; limited engagement with mostly ill-chosen source materials; no consistent argument is discernible; presentation may be too digressive or lack clear purpose. Poorly prepared illustrations and examples; accompanying materials of little or no relevance. |
Fail (lowest) | 0-19 | Severely limited: Very poor presentation; inept, insubstantial, inconsequential or absent argument; negligible or no engagement with source materials; persistent digression; very poorly prepared and presented illustrations and examples; accompanying materials of little or no relevance, or entirely absent. |
Marking Guidelines: Professional Placement
Class | % Mark | Descriptor |
I (high) | 90-100 | Exceptional: An exceptional ability to organise, reflect upon and convey a wide range of high quality learning experiences; promotional materials of a highly professional standard, expertly presented; a very mature and extremely well balanced approach is evident throughout; submission is the best reflection of the outstanding attributes of the individual; submission demonstrates exceptional engagement and authority in respect of relevant technologies and media and their value in self-promotional activities, professional (self-)presentation and the capacity for highly articulate communication with a wide audience. |
I (mid) | 80-89 | Outstanding: An extremely strong submission which is meticulously prepared and demonstrates a wealth of high quality learning; a mature reflection with admirably concision and intellectual acumen; a very good professional presentation of promotional materials, underpinned by an outstanding range of learning experiences; submission demonstrates outstanding engagement and facility with relevant technologies and media and their value in self-promotional activities, professional (self-)presentation and the capacity for articulate communication with a wide audience |
I (low) | 70-79 | Excellent: A concise, thoughtful, insightful and balanced summary of excellent learning experiences; sophisticated and articulate reflection which is balanced and informative; promotional materials of an acceptable professional standard, conveying the excellent level of expertise of the individual; submission demonstrates excellent engagement and ability with relevant technologies and media and their value in self-promotional activities, acceptable professional (self-)presentation and the capacity for articulate communication with a wide audience |
II i | 60-69 | Very good: A very good overall account of a broad range of learning experiences; materials are generally succinct and punchy; an evident an ability to prioritise, select and reject material; a very worthy reflective account, well thought through and engaging; promotional materials are of a very good standard, imaginatively prepared; submission demonstrates very good engagement and skill with relevant technologies and media and their value in self-promotional activities, proto-professional (self-) presentation and the capacity for mostly articulate communication with a wide audience |
II ii | 50-59 | Good: Reasonably detailed accounting of the activities undertaken; a clear sense of the learning experience of the individual is evident; good, if perhaps somewhat unsophisticated evaluation which may be characterized by some naïve solecisms; a reasonable range of good experience is evident though the reflection; promotional materials carefully prepared if somewhat uninspiring; submission demonstrates good engagement and some skill with relevant technologies and media and their value in self-promotional activities; contains elements of proto-professional (self-)presentation and the capacity for mostly articulate communication with a wide audience |
III | 40-49 | Adequate: An acceptable record of learning experiences undertaken; some ability to reflect upon and evaluate these experiences objectively; perhaps a somewhat ramshackle and disorganised presentation although it reveals a generally good range of activity; promotional materials acceptable if a little unfocussed; submission demonstrates adequate engagement and basic skill with relevant technologies and media and their value in self-promotional activities; contains adequate, if inconsistent, (self-) presentation, though this does not approach professional standards; submission reveals the capacity for acceptable communication with an audience |
Fail | 30-39 | Some merits: Although there may be some evidence of learning activity the materials lack focus and do not demonstrate any consistency; perhaps characterized by a mechanistic, unfocussed and essentially uncritical listing of learning which may seem rather insubstantial; promotional materials rather weak, with infelicities and inaccuracies; submission demonstrates a lack of engagement and facility with relevant technologies and media and their value in self-promotional activities, an inadequate standard of (self-) presentation and lacks the capacity for articulate communication towards an audience |
Fail (low) | 20-29 | Few merits: Very limited evidence of learning experiences; poorly organised and lacking any critical and evaluative skill; little more than a listing of what is probably a rather dubious and slight range of experience; promotional materials unacceptable and careless; submission demonstrates limited engagement and poor facility with relevant technologies and; lacks awareness of their value in self-promotional activities; reveals a poor standard of (self-)presentation and little or no capacity for articulate communication with an audience |
Fail (lowest) | 0-19 | Severely limited: Messy and disorganised; it is unclear from the presented materials the essence of the learning that has taken place; lacking any focus and detail; little or no ability to reflect upon the developmental processes of learning; promotional materials always poorly presented; submission demonstrates poor engagement and little or no facility with relevant technologies and; no understanding of their value in self-promotional activities; an extremely poor standard of (self-) presentation and no capacity for articulate communication; no sense of audience awareness |
Marking Guidelines: Reflective Portfolio
Class | % Mark | Descriptor |
I (high) | 90-100 | Exceptional: An exceptional ability to organise, reflect upon and convey a range of high-quality learning experiences; reflection is meticulously presented; a mature and well balanced approach is evident throughout; submission reflects the exceptional attributes of the individual; submission demonstrates exceptional engagement with relevant classes and grasp of key concepts and themes, exceptional presentation and the capacity for highly articulate communication with a wide audience. An exceptional understanding of context and critical issues is demonstrated. |
I (mid) | 80-89 | Outstanding: An outstanding submission which is very carefully prepared and demonstrates much high-quality learning; an insightful reflection with concision and intellectual insight; an outstanding level of presentation, underpinned by a wide range of learning experiences; submission demonstrates outstanding engagement with relevant classes and grasp of key concepts and themes, outstanding presentation and the capacity for articulate communication with a wide audience. An outstanding understanding of context and critical is demonstrated. |
I (low) | 70-79 | Excellent: A concise, thoughtful, and balanced summary of excellent learning experiences; highly competent and articulate reflection which is balanced and informative; the submission conveys an excellent level of expertise of the individual; submission demonstrates strong engagement with relevant classes and grasp of key concepts and themes, excellent presentation and the capacity for articulate communication with a wide audience. An excellent understanding of context and critical issues is demonstrated. |
II i | 60-69 | Very good: A very good account of a varied range of learning experiences; materials are mostly clear and succinct; a very good ability to prioritise, select and reject material; a very competent reflective account, mostly well thought through and engaging; submission demonstrates very good engagement with relevant classes and grasp of key concepts and themes, very good presentation and the capacity for mostly articulate communication with a wide audience. A very good understanding of context and critical issues is demonstrated. |
II ii | 50-59 | Good: Somewhat detailed accounting of the activities undertaken; a reasonably clear sense of the learning experience of the individual is evident; good, if somewhat unsophisticated evaluation which may be characterized by some naïve solecisms; a reasonable range of good experience is evident though the reflection; submission demonstrates good engagement with relevant classes and grasp of key concepts and themes; contains elements of good presentation and the capacity for good communication with a wide audience. A good understanding of context and critical issues is demonstrated. |
III | 40-49 | Adequate: An acceptable record of learning experiences undertaken; some ability to reflect upon and evaluate these experiences objectively; an adequate presentation though perhaps disorganised and containing some inconsistencies; submission reveals a generally adequate range of activity and thought; reflection a somewhat unfocussed; submission demonstrates adequate engagement with relevant classes through a limited understanding of key concepts and themes; submission reveals the capacity for acceptable communication with an audience. An adequate understanding of context and critical issues is demonstrated. |
Fail | 30-39 | Some merits: Although there may be some evidence of learning activity the reflection lacks focus and does not demonstrate sufficient consistency; perhaps characterized by a mechanistic, unfocussed and essentially uncritical listing of learning which may seem rather insubstantial; self-reflection rather superficial; submission demonstrates a lack of engagement with relevant classes and key themes, an inadequate standard of presentation, and limited capacity for articulate communication with an audience. A patchy or flawed understanding of context and critical issues is demonstrated. |
Fail (low) | 20-29 | Few merits: Very limited evidence of learning experiences; poorly organised and lacking in critical and evaluative skill; little more than a listing of facts and experience; submission demonstrates limited engagement with relevant classes, key concepts and themes; reveals a poor standard of presentation and lacks capacity for articulate communication with an audience. Very little understanding of context and critical issues is demonstrated. |
Fail (lowest) | 0-19 | Severely limited: Messy and disorganised; it is unclear from the presented materials whether basic learning has taken place; lacking any focus and detail; little or no ability to reflect upon the developmental processes of learning; reflective writing always poorly presented; submission demonstrates poor engagement and little or no facility with content of classes and key themes; an extremely poor standard of presentation and no capacity for articulate communication; no sense of audience awareness. A severely limited or complete lack of understanding of context and critical issues is demonstrated. |
Marking Guidelines: Solo Performance (options and electives)
Class | % Mark | Descriptor |
I (high) | 90-100 | Exceptional: Virtuosic playing, showing complete technical control, exceptional maturity of conception, sensitive and intellectually charged playing, always intuitive and insightful, revelatory and thought-provoking. The player conveys exceptional commitment and intensity, with compelling, exciting and consummately professional presentation. |
I (mid) | 80-89 | Outstanding: Outstanding technical command; technique always in service of interpretation, showing interpretative individuality, abundant intellectual depth, intuitive, with outstanding flair and panache. Risk-taking, provocative and challenging performances., entirely focused and controlled. |
I (low) | 70-79 | Excellent: Always fluent, with a quality of technical control that adds an exciting element to the performance. Performance with imagination, style and individuality willing to take risks, creative, thoughtful and showing flair, with excellent presentation and audience rapport. |
II i | 60-69 | Very good: Very good technical control; with rare signs of technical insecurity that do not detract from the interpretation. Interpretations are highly effective, demonstrating an awareness of structure, form and appropriate stylistic conventions. |
II ii | 50-59 | Good: Sound technique displayed, which can comfortably cope with the demands of the repertoire. Playing is generally well-shaped and consistent, though not always stylish. A generally well-projected sense of involvement in the music making. |
III | 40-49 | Adequate: An essentially secure technique in spite of some aberrations, able to match demands of repertoire chosen, showing an acceptable understanding of stylistic features of the repertoire, if at times lacking sensitivity, maturity or refinement. Some evidence of commitment and projection of character, showing a generally satisfactory audience rapport. |
Fail | 30-39 | Some merits: Certain technical merits but the performance reveals some technical deficiencies. Interpretations are patchy, with little understanding of appropriate style, presentation is generally awkward and uncomfortable, and projection limited. |
Fail (low) | 20-29 | Few merits: Significant deficiencies in technique lead to faltering and uncomfortable performances. Interpretations can be mechanical and inconsistent, with poor musicality, lacking in subtlety and stylistic awareness. Little understanding shown of how to project or present a performance. |
Fail (lowest) | 0-19 | Severely limited: Major technical deficiencies result in tentative and hesitant performances which show no consistent sense of style, and a total lack of musical sensitivity. There is an inability to understand and communicate the most elementary presentational skills. |
Marking Guidelines: Theory and Musicianship
I (high) | 90-100 | Exceptional: Comprehensive understanding demonstrated in flawless technical exercises’ independent and self-sufficient application of theoretical issues to disparate repertories; exceptional intellectual engagement and critical facility; the highest order of musicianship skills demonstrated; authoritative and original improvisation; exceptional accuracy throughout; fluent and confident realisations and arrangements with flair; exceptional application of high level aural ability. |
I (mid) | 80-89 | Outstanding: Mature, balanced and insightful, exercises consistently accurate, outstanding knowledge base and intellectual curiosity; sophisticated and original application of theory to practice; with imagination; high level of critical awareness and accuracy; a consistently high level of musicianship demonstrated; controlled and sophisticated improvisations; very high level of accuracy in realisations and arrangements, and an outstanding level of aural ability demonstrated. |
I (low) | 70-79 | Excellent: Excellent understanding of harmony and form and an ability to relate underlying principles to a variety of widely differing contexts; awareness of analytical methods well developed with the ability to apply principles to new repertory with independence, imagination and insight; excellent level of accuracy in exercises and arrangements, which have an instinctive feel for style; an excellent overall level of musicianship; assured improvising; confident, fluent realisations, and demonstrating an excellent musical ear. |
II i | 60-69 | Very good: Clear and consistent application of sound knowledge of theory to a variety of repertory; a very good and consistent application of analytical methods to performance, arrangement, or composition; with some insight; very good level of accuracy in exercises which have fluency and a good feel for the style; mostly confident and accurate musicianship; a degree of imagination in improvisation if not always fluent with an ability to interact effectively; consistently good realisations, a high level of aural ability shown. |
II ii | 50-59 | Good: A good understanding of harmony and form and an ability to effectively relate and apply this knowledge outside of the context in which it was demonstrated; a sound understanding of relevant analytical methods and a good, if not consistent, application of these to performance, arrangement, or composition; a good general understanding of compositional methods and structures; generally good degree of accuracy and fluency in exercises; if not always consistent, a good general level of accuracy in musicianship; improvisation with a certain fluency if rather unimaginative; errors do not significantly detract. Some evidence of good application of the musical ear to written work. |
III | 40-49 | Adequate: A broad understanding of harmony and form as it pertains to particular repertories and composers; a basic understanding of relevant analytical methods and an elementary ability to apply these to performance, arrangement, or composition; a basic understanding of compositional methods and structures; although with errors, an acceptable degree of accuracy and some fluency in exercises; some ability to improvise alone and in ensemble; basically sound realisations although with a number of errors. Aural ability inconsistently applied. |
Fail | 30-39 | Some merit: A patchy understanding of harmony and form as it pertains to particular repertories and composers; although some of the more basic issues associated with analytical methods studied are understood there is an inability to engage with the core issues and apply these successfully to other works; exercises contain too many errors; arrangements exhibit inadequate understanding; very patchy work which does not reveal sound musicianship skills; inconsistent and too often flawed; faltering improvisations. Some weaknesses in the musical ear, memory, and in the processing of musical information. |
Fail (low) | 20-29 | Few merits: Limited understanding of harmony and form; limited understanding of analytical methods studied and a consequent ineffectual application of these to other musical works; exercises and arrangements are error-ridden; little grasp of the task to hand; very little accuracy; poor improvisation; very limited ability to hear and reproduce elements of music. |
Fail (lowest) | 0-19 | Severely limited: Negligible understanding of harmony and form; the lack of understanding denies a sensible theoretical engagement with other repertories; exercises mostly incorrect; arrangements demonstrate severely limited knowledge and understanding; work is mostly inaccurate; improvisations flounder; almost total failure to hear and reproduce elements of music. |
Marking Guidelines: Tutor Report
Class | % Mark | Descriptor |
I (high) | 90-100 | Exceptional: The student has been exceptionally well prepared, demonstrating exemplary professionalism in their conduct at rehearsals/ meetings/ tutorials. The student has shown exceptional initiative, which has facilitated their own and/or others’ learning and participation. The student has attained professional standards of self-presentation, interaction with peers and professionals and has shown mature and highly-developed interpersonal communication skills in the activity(-ies) undertaken. |
I (mid) | 80-89 | Outstanding: The student has been outstanding in their preparation and professionalism. They have demonstrated assured professionalism in their conduct at rehearsals/ meetings/ tutorials. The student has shown clear initiative, which has facilitated their own and/or others’ learning and participation. The student has attained professional standards of self-presentation, interaction with peers and professionals and has shown superior interpersonal communication skills in the activity(-ies) undertaken. |
I (low) | 70-79 | Excellent: The student has been excellent in their preparation and professionalism. They have demonstrated appreciable professionalism in their conduct at rehearsals/ meetings/ tutorials. The student has shown initiative, which has facilitated their own and/ or others’ learning and participation. The student has a clear grasp of professional standards of self-presentation, interaction with peers and professionals and has put into practice interpersonal communication skills in the activity(-ies) undertaken. |
II i | 60-69 | Very good: The student has been very good in their preparation and professionalism. They have demonstrated a very good professional attitude in their conduct at rehearsals/ meetings/ tutorials. The student has shown some initiative, which has facilitated their own and/or others’ learning and participation. The student is able to grasp professional standards of self-presentation, engage with peers and professionals and has explored interpersonal communication skills in the activity(-ies) undertaken. |
II ii | 50-59 | Good: The student has been good in their preparation and professionalism. They have demonstrated a good attitude, if not yet fully developed maturity in relation to their conduct at rehearsals/ meetings/ tutorials. The student has shown a little initiative, which has facilitated their own and/or others’ learning and participation. The student aspires to professional standards of self-presentation, and relates reasonably with peers and professionals and has developed some interpersonal communication skills in the activity(-ies) undertaken. |
III | 40-49 | Adequate: The student has been acceptable, if a little inconsistent, in their preparation and professionalism. They have demonstrated a fair attitude, which nevertheless requires a development in maturity in relation to their conduct at rehearsals/meetings/tutorials. The student has shown limited initiative, which has potentially facilitated their own and/or others’ learning and participation. The student understands professional standards of self-presentation, and relates acceptably, if sometimes naively and with a lack of focus with peers and professionals. The student has developed limited interpersonal communication skills in the activity(-ies) undertaken. |
Fail | 30-39 | Some merits: The student has been inconsistent and at times unacceptable in their preparation and professionalism. They have demonstrated a variable attitude, which requires a development in maturity in relation to their conduct at rehearsals/meetings/tutorials. The student has shown no discernible initiative, and has not facilitated their own and/or others’ learning and participation. The student does not consistently observe professional standards of self-presentation, and relates naively and with a pronounced lack of focus with peers and professionals. The student has developed little by way of interpersonal communication skills in the activity(-ies) undertaken. |
Fail (low) | 20-29 | Few merits: The student has been wholly inconsistent and often unacceptable in their preparation and professionalism. They have demonstrated a highly variable attitude, which requires a significant development in maturity in relation to their conduct at rehearsals/ meetings/ tutorials. The student has shown a lack of initiative, and has not facilitated, and undermined at times, their own and/or others’ learning and participation. The student does not observe professional standards of self-presentation, and relates poorly and with a worrying lack of focus with peers and professionals. The student has demonstrated no evidence of interpersonal communication skills in the activity(-ies) undertaken. |
Fail (lowest) | 0-19 | Severely Limited: The student has been unacceptably poor and remiss in their preparation and professionalism. They have demonstrated a problematic attitude, which requires a fundamental development in maturity in relation to their conduct at rehearsals/meetings/tutorials. The student has shown a profound lack of initiative, and has undermined their own and/or others’ learning and participation. The student is fundamentally disorganised and shows no awareness of or aspiration towards professional standards of self-presentation. The student relates extremely poorly and unprofessionally with peers and professionals. The student has demonstrated a concerning lack of interpersonal communication skills in the activity(-ies) undertaken. |
Marking Guidelines: Viva Voce
Class | % Mark | Descriptor |
I (high) | 90-100 | Exceptional: An exceptional ability to communicate, reflect upon and convey a wide range of high quality learning experiences; a very mature and extremely well balanced approach is evident throughout; viva is the best reflection of the outstanding attributes of the individual, who shows an exceptional reflective and creative response to questions posed, proving an exceptionally mature, knowledgeable and considered awareness of the student’s own learning experiences. |
I (mid) | 80-89 | Outstanding: An extremely strong viva which is meticulously prepared and demonstrates a wealth of high quality learning; a mature reflection with admirably concision and intellectual acumen; excellent communication skills demonstrating clarity of thought, and reacting to questions posed with outstanding creative and reflective responses. |
I (low) | 70-79 | Excellent: Concise and imaginative responses to questions posed about the learning experiences; sophisticated and articulate reflection; excellent skills in communication demonstrating a balanced approach to expressing own viewpoint. |
II i | 60-69 | Very good: Very good responses to questions posed; a good overall account of the learning experiences; an evident ability to evaluate and place it in broader context ; engaging communication with the ability to express own viewpoint. |
II ii | 50-59 | Good: Reasonably detailed response to questions posed; a clear understanding of the learning experience of the individual is evident; good, if somewhat unsophisticated evaluation; a reasonable ability to communicate own viewpoint if somewhat uninspiring in presentation. |
III | 40-49 | Adequate: An acceptable response to the questions posed; some ability to reflect upon and evaluate the learning experience although a somewhat disorganised presentation; an adequate ability to communicate own viewpoint. |
Fail | 30-39 | Some merits: The responses lacked clarity and signs of preparation; little if no ability to reflect upon and evaluate the learning experience; unfocused presentation; evidence of a lack of ability to communicate own viewpoint. |
Fail (low) | 20-29 | Few merits: Very limited responses; the presentation lacked any attempt to reflect upon and evaluate the learning experience; poorly organised and lacking any critical and evaluative skill; no attempt to communicate own viewpoint |
Fail (lowest) | 0-19 | Severely limited: Shoddy and disorganised; it is unclear from the responses that any learning has taken place; lacking any focus and detail; little or no ability to reflect upon or communicate the developmental processes of learning. |
Marking Guidelines: Written Assignments
Class | % Mark | Descriptor |
I (high) | 90-100 | Exceptional: Rare degree of insight at this level, revealing an exceptional intellectual curiosity and maturity; impressive ability to engage with, process and develop disparate materials in written work of notable originality; sophisticated argument, expression and presentation of ideas, research, arguments and perspectives. |
I (mid) | 80-89 | Outstanding: Mature and balanced written work demonstrating a high level of engagement with source materials and a considerable degree of intellectual independence; consistently high standard of analysis, argument, research or discussion pertinent to the subject area; very high standard of presentation and communication. |
I (low) | 70-79 | Excellent: Discerning, consistent and logical written work; thorough engagement with appropriate source materials; excellent application of analysis, argument, research or discussion pertinent to the subject area; some measure of original thinking; high standard of presentation and communication. |
II i | 60-69 | Very good: Well researched work employing a strong selection of appropriate source materials; effective and sustained argument with few weaknesses; very good analysis, research and discussion pertinent to subject; very good overall level if presentation and communication. |
II ii | 50-59 | Good: Work that employs a reasonable selection of appropriate source materials; largely effective and, for the most part, well prepared; some useful analysis or discussion of evidence pertinent to subject; fairly cohesive argument despite some weaknesses or significant errors; reasonably good standard of presentation and communication. |
III | 40-49 | Adequate: Written work demonstrating some ability to sustain a coherent argument despite significant errors and weaknesses; limited employment of useful or high-quality sources, research, or evidence; broadly competent if inconsistent levels of presentation and communication. |
Fail | 30-39 | Some merit: Although there is some attempt to engage with source materials and construct an argument, the work contains too many very significant errors or areas of weakness; relevant methods are not effectively deployed to support the argument; presentation and communication are unclear or otherwise problematic. |
Fail (low) | 20-29 | Few merits: Very few source materials employed; poor application of technical and analytical methods; weak and insubstantial arguments; regular digression from the subject matter; poorly presented and communicated. |
Fail (lowest) | 0-19 | Severely limited: Negligible or no engagement with source materials; inept and inconsequential application of methods relevant to topic; absent, confusing, or fundamentally incorrect arguments; very poorly presented and communicated. |