Guidance on UG submissions reporting data from other people – from original research involving human participation to “personal communications”
All research involving other people – asking them, for example, to keep diaries, respond to survey questionnaires, be observed or interviewed, or recorded for social media videos or podcasts – has to be approved by the RNCM Research Ethics Committee. This policy was agreed by Academic Board in 2006. Students collecting data as part of the year 4 Creative Project module must complete the ethics form on Moodle, which is then reviewed by the Chair of the Research Ethics Committee.
Undergraduate students should normally NOT carry out research involving other people unless they are undertaking the 3rd and 4th year electives Applied Music Psychology: Theory, Practice and Research or Principles and Foundations of Music Education. In these electives they make an application for ethical approval to the RNCM Research Ethics Committee, having read the RNCM Good Research Conduct Policy, the BPS Code of Human Research Ethics and the UG Music Psychology Guidelines. They learn how to raise appropriate questions. They address the ethical issues associated with carrying out research involving other people by ensuring that participants (in studies using methods such as observations and experiments) and respondents (to questionnaires and in the context of interviews) have given their informed consent, are guaranteed anonymity and/or confidentiality and are debriefed. They are introduced to methodological issues such as bias, demand characteristics, reliability and validity, and find out how to analyse and interpret the data they gather in the course of their investigations.
4th-year students on the Creative Project module who wish to undertake a research project involving participants must be a) supervised by a member of staff who has experience of research ethics and b) complete the online form for ethical approval, which is then reviewed by the Chair of the committee.
It is clearly valuable for student composers and performers to talk with, and learn from each other. Students should NOT, however, report conversations in submissions as though they were research findings. They should be regarded, rather, as “personal communications”, used only for the purpose of enhancing practice. Examples might be a performer demonstrating the capabilities of her instrument to a composer, or one performer talking about his experience of playing a specific piece or singing a role to another. While holding conversations (face-to-face, via telephone, Skype or e-mail) would not normally require ethical approval, students asking questions of their peers (and others) should nevertheless obtain the explicit consent of their interlocutors to make use of their responses, and acknowledge the contribution they have made to the student’s learning. They should be given the opportunity to check transcripts if the conversation has been recorded, and to satisfy themselves that paraphrases of what they said are accurate.
The standard way of citing personal communications (letters, e-mails and other person-toperson communication) using APA-style formatting, for example, is to cite in the body of the text (essay, project report, dissertation etc.) the communicator’s name, the fact that it was personal communication, and the date of the communication.
(S. Lawrence, personal communication, 29 October 2013).
E. Masson also reported that many of her students had difficulties distinguishing between research findings and anecdotal evidence (personal communication, 26 October 2013).
Do NOT include personal communication in the list of references or bibliography. If you include a personal communication in your submission, however, please supply evidence such as an e-mail from the person who provided the communication saying they agree to your making use of it and are confident that they have not been misrepresented.
Chair of RNCM Research Ethics Committee
For more information see Moodle page under ‘Research’ and ‘Research ethics’