SECTION 10: MARKING GUIDELINES

These guidelines should be used in conjunction with Module Outlines and are to be used and interpreted in relation to the relevant Level of study and the Learning Outcomes for the Course Option:

Performance Assessment

Popular Music Assessment

Popular Music Portfolio

Conducting

Composition Portfolio

Dissertation and Written Project Work

Ensemble Recital and Performance Assessment

Presentations

Cross-cultural approaches to Musicianship

Professional Audition

Recording Project

Self-Evaluation and Evidence-Based Portfolio

Viva Voce

Artistic Project

Presenting Research

For International Artist please see Section 5.

Marking Guidelines: Performance Assessment

Class

% Band

Marking Guidelines

Distinction

90–100

Exceptional musicianship and virtuosic technique at the highest professional level; profound artistry and originality demonstrated in authoritative and inspirational interpretations; exceptional stage presence and audience engagement; impressively imaginative programming; an exceptional artistic identity demonstrating ease in taking creative risks and achieving them successfully

80–89

Outstanding musicianship and technique at a high professional level; creative imagination and individuality demonstrated in authoritative and insightful interpretations; outstanding stage presence and audience engagement; highly imaginative programming; outstanding artistic identity and a willingness to take some creative risks and achieve them successfully

70–79

Excellent musicianship and technique at a professional level; imaginative, individual and successful interpretations; commanding stage presence and communication; imaginative programming, a persuasive artistic identity is evident, with some willingness to take creative risks and achieve them convincingly

Pass

65–69

Very good musicianship and technical control; balanced and convincing interpretations with musical personality and purpose with some very effective moments; very good stage presence and sense of communication, satisfying programming and a sense of artistic identity is emerging.

60–64

Good musicianship and technical control; coherent and mostly successful interpretations, showing some individuality and imagination; good stage presence and communication, effective programming and sense of character as a performer is evident.

55–59

Competent musicianship and technique are demonstrated; while interpretations are mostly persuasive, they are not always consistent and coherent; acceptable stage presence and communication; programming is appropriate and there is some character in the performances.

50–54

Adequate musicianship and technique are demonstrated, although with some mistakes and inconsistency; some stylistic awareness but interpretations have patchy, unconvincing moments; adequate stage presence and presentation although programming could demonstrate more imagination.

Fail

40–49

Some musicianship and technique are displayed, but there are frequent, uncomfortable moments; interpretations have some merits but are unreliable; stage presence may be inadequate and programming ill-judged.

0–39

Major deficiencies in musicianship and technique, performances are mostly uncomfortable and naïve; little or no stylistic awareness and no convincing interpretation; hesitant and tentative stage presence and poor programming.

Note: The guidelines may be used and interpreted:

  1. in relation to the relevant level of study, module aims, learning outcomes and the repertoire performed.
  2. in cases of disagreement between professional examiners; they are not intended to replace their expert judgments.
  3. to provide a framework for oral and/or written feedback to students to enhance and promote your subsequent learning and development.
  4. with the understanding that a performance may have qualities crossing bands, the panel will arrive at the mark reflecting the overall sense of the performance

Marking Guidelines: Popular Music Assessment

Class

%

Band

Marking Guidelines

Distinction

90–100

Exceptional ability and stage presence at the highest professional level; profound and inspiring interpretations impressively suited to the repertoire; exceptional audience engagement; exceptionally imaginative programming including, where appropriate, completely successful original work; demonstrating ease in taking creative risks and achieving them successfully, a highly impressive individuality is evident; where applicable, original compositions and/or portfolio demonstrate consummate craftsmanship, individuality and character.

80–89

Outstanding ability and stage presence at a professional level; authoritative and insightful interpretations entirely suited to the repertoire; outstanding audience engagement; highly imaginative programming including, where appropriate, successful original work; a willingness to take creative risks and achieve them successfully, an impressive individuality is evident; where applicable, original compositions and/or portfolio demonstrate outstanding craftsmanship, individuality and character.

70–79

Excellent technical facility and stage presence is displayed throughout, at a professional level; authoritative and mature musicianship; high levels of stage presence and communication; creative programming, including where appropriate strong original work; an engaging individuality is evident; where applicable, original work and/or portfolio

presented is highly refined, individual, and impressively imaginative.

Pass

65–69

The technique throughout is secure; balanced and convincing interpretations with a clear musical personality and purpose; very good sense of audience communication, satisfying programming and, where applicable, very good original work and/or portfolio is presented that is effective and has a clear sense of individuality.

60–64

Some good technical facility throughout; coherent interpretations, with some performing showing individuality and imagination; engaging presentation, confident and assured, with good programming and, where applicable, good original work and/or portfolio in which a sense of character is evident.

55–59

A competent technique is shown throughout; fair stylistic awareness, although performing is not always consistent and coherent; sense of involvement in the music- making projected to audience; programming shows some imagination and there is some character in the performance; where applicable, original work and/or portfolio presented demonstrates some sense of character.

50–54

The technical demands of the repertoire are adequately negotiated, although with some errors and inconsistency; some stylistic awareness but interpretations have patchy, unconvincing moments; acceptable projection and presentation although programming could demonstrate more imagination and, where applicable, original work and/or portfolio

presented is of inconsistent quality.

Fail

40–49

Some technical merits are displayed, but there are frequent, uncomfortable moments; unreliable interpretations, rather monochrome, somewhat mechanical and unvarying; ill- refined presentation and unimaginative programming; where original work and/or portfolio is presented it is somewhat derivative.

0–39

Major technical deficiencies, performances are mostly uncomfortable and naïve; little or no stylistic awareness and no convincing interpretation; hesitant and tentative projection and poor programming; where applicable, original work and/or portfolio presented is

unimaginative and uninspiring.

Note: The guidelines may be used and interpreted:

  1. in relation to the relevant level of study, module aims, learning outcomes and the repertoire performed.
  2. in cases of disagreement between professional examiners; they are not intended to replace their expert judgments.
  3. to provide a framework for oral and/or written feedback to students to enhance and promote your subsequent learning and development.
  4. with the understanding that a performance may have qualities traversing bands, it is for the panel to arrive at the mark reflecting the overall sense of the performance.

Marking Guidelines: Popular Music Portfolio

Class

%

Band

Marking Guidelines

Distinction

90–100

Exceptional qualities of originality, individuality and conceptual coherence are shown. There is a synergy of technique, theoretical understanding and imagination, and the work articulates aims of great contemporary relevance that are exceptionally well-formulated. All materials are realised to an exceptional professional standard, in the form of music notation, studio production, performance or systems design, as relevant

80–89

Demonstrates outstanding qualities of originality, individuality and conceptual coherence. Technique, theoretical understanding and imagination are very convincingly integrated, whilst aims are outstandingly well-formulated and of significant contemporary relevance. All materials are realised to an outstanding professional standard, in the form of music notation, studio production, performance or systems design, as relevant

70–79

Excellent qualities of originality, individuality and conceptual coherence are demonstrated. Technique, theoretical understanding and imagination are convincingly integrated, whilst aims are excellently formulated and of contemporary relevance. All materials are realised to an excellent professional standard, in the form of music notation, studio production, performance or systems design, as relevant

Pass

65–69

Exhibits very good levels of originality, individuality and conceptual coherence. Technique, theoretical understanding and imagination are integrated and aims are very well formulated and of some contemporary relevance. All materials are realised to a professional standard, in the form of music notation, studio production, performance or systems design, as relevant.

60–64

Shows clear signs of originality, coherence and individuality. There is a confident use of a range of relevant techniques, explored with imagination. Work is informed by contemporary and relevant theoretical ideas. All materials are realised to a good standard, in the form of music notation, studio production, performance or systems design, as relevant.

55–59

Some degree of originality, coherence and individuality is shown. A range of techniques is applied effectively with some evidence of imagination. Work is informed by contemporary and relevant theoretical ideas to some degree. All materials are realised to a fair standard, in the form of music notation, studio production, performance or systems design, as relevant.

50–54

Demonstrates a satisfactory degree of originality, coherence and individuality. An understanding of techniques is apparent, with some evidence of imaginative application, but with some errors and inconsistency. Work is informed by contemporary and relevant theoretical ideas to some degree, albeit patchy and unconvincing in places. All materials are realised to an acceptable standard, in the form of music notation, studio production, performance or systems design, as relevant.

Fail

40–49

Some creative merits are displayed, but the degree of originality, coherence and individuality is unsatisfactory. Understanding of techniques and their application is insufficient. Work is not adequately informed by contemporary and relevant theoretical ideas, and materials are not realised to an acceptable standard (be this in the form of music notation, studio production, performance or systems design, as relevant).

0–39

Major creative deficiencies, with little or no originality, coherence or individuality. Understanding of techniques and their application is negligible. Work shows little or no evidence of being informed by contemporary and relevant theoretical ideas, and materials fall significantly short of acceptable standards (be this in the form of music notation, studio production, performance or systems design, as relevant).

Note: The guidelines may be used and interpreted:

  1. in relation to the relevant level of study, module aims, learning outcomes and the repertoire involved.
  2. in cases of disagreement between professional examiners; they are not intended to replace their expert judgments.
  3. to provide a framework for oral and/or written feedback to students to enhance and promote your subsequent learning and development.
  4. with the understanding that a portfolio may have qualities traversing bands, it is for the panel to arrive at the mark reflecting the overall sense of the performance.

Marking Guidelines: Conducting

Class

% Band

Marking Guidelines

Distinction

90–100

Virtuosic flair and technical control throughout at the highest professional level; exceptionally creative and original imagination in authoritative and inspiring interpretations; exceptional presence and audience engagement; exceptionally imaginative conducting, and an ease in taking creative risks and achieving them successfully, an extremely impressive individuality and commanding stage presence is evident

80–89

Outstanding technical control throughout at a high professional level; high levels of creative imagination in personal and insightful interpretations; outstanding presence and audience engagement; imaginative conducting overall, and a willingness to take creative risks and achieve them successfully, an impressive individuality and commanding stage presence is evident

70–79

Excellent technical facility is displayed throughout, at a professional level; refined, authoritative and mature musicianship; high levels of stage presence and communication; imaginative conducting with some individuality, and a very fine stage presence is evident.

Pass

65–69

The technique throughout is secure; balanced and convincing interpretations with a clear musical personality and purpose; very good sense of audience communication, very good, solid, conducting with a degree of individuality

60–64

Some good technical facility, in all repertoire presented; coherent interpretations, with some performing showing individuality and imagination; engaging presentation, confident and assured, with good conducting and a sense of character

55–59

A competent technique is shown, in all repertoire presented; fair stylistic awareness, although performing is not always consistent and coherent; sense of involvement in the music-making projected to audience; there is able conducting and there is some character in the performance

50–54

The technical demands of the repertoire are adequately negotiated, although with some error and inconsistency; some stylistic awareness but interpretations have patchy, unconvincing moments; acceptable projection and presentation although conducting could demonstrate more imagination

Fail

40–49

Some technical merits are displayed, but there are frequent, uncomfortable moments; unreliable interpretations, rather monochrome, somewhat mechanical and unvarying; ill-refined presentation and unimaginative conducting

0–39

Major technical deficiencies, directing is mostly uncomfortable and naïve; little or no stylistic awareness and no convincing interpretation; hesitant and tentative projection and poor conducting overall

Note: The guidelines may be used and interpreted:

  1. in relation to the relevant level of study, module aims, learning outcomes and the repertoire performed.
  2. in cases of disagreement between professional examiners; they are not intended to replace their expert judgments.
  3. to provide a framework for oral and/or written feedback to students to enhance and promote your subsequent learning and development.
  4. with the understanding that a performance may have qualities traversing bands, it is for the panel to arrive at the mark reflecting the overall sense of the performance.

Marking Guidelines: Composition Portfolio

Class

% Band

Marking Guidelines

Distinction

90–100

Exceptional technical command at a high professional level shown in all aspects of the portfolio; exceptionally creative imagination and originality in authoritative and inspiring compositions where creative risks are successfully achieved; exceptional standard of presentation

80–89

Outstanding technical command at a professional level shown in all aspects of the portfolio; outstanding level of creative imagination and individuality in authoritative and insightful compositions where creative risks are convincingly achieved; outstanding standard of presentation

70–79

Excellent compositional technique approaching a professional level in all aspects of the portfolio; refined, imaginative and authoritative compositions, with a convincing and developed individual style; very high standard of presentation

Pass

65–69

A very good compositional technique, imaginatively and interestingly engaged across the portfolio; balanced and varied works, with a developing individual style; very good idiomatic writing for media chosen; high standard of presentation

60–64

A good compositional technique, consistently displayed in the portfolio; coherent, imaginative compositions, with a clearly emerging personal style and good understanding of idiomatic possibilities of media chosen; good standard of presentation

55–59

A competent compositional technique is shown, throughout the portfolio; reasonable sense of idiomatic writing for the media chosen, within embryonic personal style; fair standards of presentation

50–54

An adequate compositional technique is displayed; some imagination is evident, even if this is inconsistent across the works included in the portfolio; acceptable standards of presentation

Fail

40–49

Technical insecurities are numerous; notes are ‘worked’ with little understanding of their effect in performance; derivative, rather lacking in imagination; presentation is weak

0–39

Bland and unimaginative compositions with a multitude of technical errors; poor understanding of instrumental idioms; very poor ability to sustain ideas over appropriate durations; presentation is very poor

Note: The guidelines may be used and interpreted:

  1. in relation to the relevant level of study, module aims, learning outcomes and the repertoire performed.
  2. in cases of disagreement between professional examiners; they are not intended to replace their expert judgments.
  3. to provide a framework for oral and/or written feedback to students to enhance and promote your subsequent learning and development.
  4. with the understanding that a portfolio may have qualities traversing bands, it is for the panel to arrive at the mark reflecting the overall sense of the portfolio

Marking Guidelines: Dissertation and Written Project Work

Class

% Band

Marking Guidelines

Distinction

High

80–100

Exceptional. Demonstrates outstanding appreciation of relevant academic debates, published scholarship, appropriate source materials (including evidence of current practice in the field or type of activity), and/or contemporary musical and social contexts; very high critical, analytical, imaginative and interpretative insight; and complete fluency of expression, combined with exceptional presentational skills, with very few typographical errors and/or other solecisms. Approaching a high professional level of scholarship and presentation.

Low 70–79

Excellent. Demonstrates excellent appreciation of relevant academic debates, published scholarship, appropriate source materials (including evidence of current practice in the field or type of activity), and/or contemporary musical and social contexts; a high level of critical, analytical, imaginative and interpretative insight; and a very high degree of fluency in expression, combined with excellent presentational skills, with few typographical errors and/or other solecisms. Approaching a professional level of scholarship and presentation.

Pass

60–69

Good. Demonstrates sound appreciation of relevant academic debates, published scholarship, appropriate source materials (including evidence of current practice in the field or type of activity), and/or contemporary musical and social contexts; a secure level of critical, analytical, imaginative and interpretative insight; and a high degree of fluency in expression, combined with good presentational skills which may nevertheless be occasionally marred by typographical errors and/or other solecisms.

50–59

Adequate. Demonstrates adequate appreciation of the relevant academic debates, published scholarship and appropriate source material; some limited evidence of critical, analytical, imaginative and interpretative insight, though without consistency; and adequate though in places flawed expression, combined with acceptable presentational skills, which may nevertheless be marred by typographical errors and/or other solecisms.

Fail

40–49

Few Merits. Although there is some attempt to engage with source materials, the work is overly reliant on subjective opinion; the thesis is unconvincing; analytical and critical methods are not effectively deployed in support of the argument; too many errors in expression and presentation.

0–39

Severely Limited. Negligible engagement with source materials; insufficient and inconsequential application of analytical and critical methods; insubstantial arguments; very poorly presented.

Note: The guidelines may be used and interpreted:

  1. in relation to the relevant level of study, module aims, learning outcomes and the repertoire performed.
  2. in cases of disagreement between professional examiners; they are not intended to replace their expert judgments.
  3. to provide a framework for oral and/or written feedback to students to enhance and promote your subsequent learning and development.

Marking Guidelines: Ensemble Recital and Performance Assessment

Criteria

  1. Technical facility: tonal control and production; diction; posture; finger work; agility; reliability
  2. Musicianship, Musicality, Style: repertoire chosen; phrasing; understanding structure; role play (solo, ensemble, accompaniment); working within section
  3. Presentation: ensemble personality and character; body language; interactivity; projection; rapport

Class

% Band

Technique

Musicianship, Musicality, Style

Presentation & Communication

Distinction

Exceptional. Virtuosic;

Exceptional. Exceptional

Exceptional. Exceptional

80-100

outstanding; complete

maturity of conception;

commitment and intensity

technical control at a

sensitive and intellectually

conveyed; with total authority;

high professional level

charged playing; always

compelling, exciting and

intuitive and insightful;

consummate professional

revelatory, thought-provoking

presentation

Excellent. Excellent

Excellent. Interpretative

Excellent. Entirely focused

70-79

technical command;

individuality; abundant

and controlled; authoritative

with a quality of control

intellectual depth; intuitive;

performances

that adds an exciting

outstanding flair and

convincing; committed;

element to the

panache; performances that

excellent presentation and

performance at a

are provocative and

audience rapport

professional level

challenging; risk taking; on

the edge

Pass

Good. Good technical

Good. Highly effective

Good. Committed playing; the

60-69

control; rare problems

interpretations which

listener is aware of real

in intonation,

demonstrate an awareness of

ensemble performer

passagework, diction

structure, form and

commitment; very well

etc. do not detract

appropriate stylistic

projected performances

conventions; coherent and

balanced ensemble playing

Adequate. Sound

Adequate. Consistent, if not

Adequate. Fair

50-59

technique displayed,

always stylish playing;

presentational skills with a

which can comfortably

generally well-shaped

sense of involvement in the

cope with the demands

music-making; generally well

of the repertoire

projected

Fail

Few Merits. Certain

Few Merits. Patchy

Few Merits. A scarcely

40-49

technical merits, in

understanding of style

satisfactory audience rapport,

spite of some

pertinent to the repertory, at

presentation; some evidence of

aberrations; able to

times lacking sensitivity;

commitment and projection of

match demands of

cogent if somewhat

individual/ensemble character

repertoire chosen,

undeveloped readings; raw

but with some

musicality; may be somewhat

technical errors

unrefined

Severely Limited.

Severely Limited.

Severely Limited. Little

0-39

Significant deficiencies

Mechanical and inconsistent

understanding of, or ability to

in technique, leading to

interpretations; poor

project, appropriate

faltering and

individual and collective

presentational skills.

uncomfortable

musicality; lacking any

performances

subtlety and stylistic

awareness

Note: The guidelines may be used and interpreted:

  1. in relation to the relevant level of study, module aims, learning outcomes and the repertoire performed.
  2. in cases of disagreement between professional examiners; they are not intended to replace their expert judgments.
  3. to provide a framework for oral and/or written feedback to students to enhance and promote your subsequent learning and development.

Marking Guidelines: Presentation

Criteria

  1. Powers of critical reflection
  2. Ability to communicate and field questions
  3. Presentational skills

Class

% Band

Descriptor

Marking Guidelines

Distinction

80-100

Exceptional

At a high professional level, an exceptional ability to communicate, reflect upon and convey insights into the chosen topic(s); an extremely mature and well-balanced approach is evident throughout, with outstanding deployment of research skills

70-79

Excellent

At a professional level, an extremely strong presentation which is meticulously prepared and demonstrates a high- quality investigation into the chosen topic(s); a mature approach demonstrating admirable concision and intellectual acumen; excellent communication skills demonstrating clarity of thought

Pass

60-69

Good

A very good overall presentation on the chosen topic(s); an evident ability to evaluate and place subject matter in a broader context; engaging communication with the ability to express own viewpoint

50-59

Adequate

A reasonably clear presentation and preparation is evident; fair, if perhaps somewhat unsophisticated investigation into the chosen topic(s); a reasonable ability to communicate own viewpoint if somewhat uninspiring in presentation

Fail

40-49

Few Merits

Some ability, albeit incomplete, present on the chosen topic(s), albeit with a somewhat disorganised approach; an inability to communicate either one’s own viewpoint or to summarise the views of others

0-39

Severely Limited

Lacking clarity and signs of preparation; little if no ability to reflect upon and evaluate the learning experience; unfocussed presentation; evidence of a lack of ability to communicate own viewpoint

Note: The guidelines may be used and interpreted:

  1. in relation to the relevant level of study, module aims, learning outcomes and the repertoire performed.
  2. in cases of disagreement between professional examiners; they are not intended to replace their expert judgments.
  3. to provide a framework for oral and/or written feedback to students to enhance and promote your subsequent learning and development.

Marking Guidelines: Cross-cultural approaches to Musicianship

Criteria

  1. Practical skills of arranging and improvisation
  2. Aural and notational skills in transcribing from a recording
  3. Organisational skills in preparing and presenting a live performance
  4. Reflective skills in providing an account of the process of preparing and presenting work.

Class

% Band

Descriptor

Marking Guidelines

Distinction

80-100

Exceptional

An exceptional ability to improvise, transcribe and/or arrange idiomatically at a high professional level,; an exceptionally high level of presentational and organisational skills

70-79

Excellent

An extremely strong ability to improvise, transcribe and/or arrange idiomatically, realising an enterprising and imaginative project with excellent attention to detail; an excellent level of presentational and organisational skills

Pass

60-69

Good

Very good level of both transcription/arrangement and performance and/or improvisation, combined with a good overall account of the learning experiences

50-59

Adequate

A competent realisation of the task, with adequate imagination and/or fluency. Notation, timing, presentation and account are reasonably well organised

Fail

40-49

Few Merits

Some competency shown in writing for instruments, notation, and aural accuracy, but marred by uncertainty and imprecision in organisation and sense of timing, Written

account peremptory or lacking in the necessary detail.

0-39

Severely Limited

Poor preparation, a lack of basic competence in transcription or improvisation, and evidence of lack of

engagement with the project

Note: The guidelines may be used and interpreted:

  1. in relation to the relevant level of study, module aims, learning outcomes and the repertoire performed.
  2. in cases of disagreement between professional examiners; they are not intended to replace their expert judgments.
  3. to provide a framework for oral and/or written feedback to students to enhance and promote your subsequent learning and development.

Marking Guidelines: Professional Audition

Criteria

  1. Technical facility: tonal production and control; sight reading skills
  2. Musicianship, Musicality, Style
  3. Preparation and understanding of context of excerpts (where applicable)

Class

% Band

Descriptor

Marking Guidelines

Distinction

80-100

Exceptional

Virtuosic command over technical demands of the audition repertoire at a high professional level; exceptional accuracy, musicality and awareness of context demonstrated in orchestral excerpts and sight-reading; test pieces with

exceptional musicality, control and impressive projection

70-79

Excellent

A highly impressive audition at a professional level with fluent and imaginative performing throughout; sight reading is assured and accurate with an impressive degree of detail

conveyed to the listener; instinctively musical; test pieces of outstanding musical and technical level

Pass

60-69

Good

Technically very able and the demands of the audition are mostly very well addressed; though the sight-reading tests may well have a lack of detail in some respects, overall there

is good deal of coherence and musicality; test pieces are very well prepared and convincingly presented

50-59

Adequate

Technically sound if sometimes a little inconsistent; sight reading has reasonable shape, if lacking detail at times and with some error; some sense of context and musical style is portrayed; test pieces are mostly well prepared, on the whole musically convincing and coherent if never particularly

inspiring

Fail

40-49

Few Merits

Reasonably coherent if sometimes faltering performances of the audition repertoire; sight reading that may have some degree of continuity though lacking detail and a sense of

context; test repertoire is reasonably competent, though often unimaginative and lacking character

0-39

Severely Limited

Although there are elements of the audition that may be satisfactory, in totality it is wanting; there may be repetitious weakness and stumbles in sight reading; poor understanding of the context and requirements of excerpts; test pieces may be somewhat lacking in musical judgment and technical

fluency

Note: The guidelines may be used and interpreted:

  1. in relation to the relevant level of study, module aims, learning outcomes and the repertoire performed.
  2. in cases of disagreement between professional examiners; they are not intended to replace their expert judgments.
  3. to provide a framework for oral and/or written feedback to students to enhance and promote your subsequent learning and development.

Marking Guidelines: Recording Project

Criteria

  1. Musicianship, Musicality, Style: repertoire chosen;
  2. Powers of critical reflection
  3. Ability to summarise, contextualise, organise and edit recorded materials
  4. Presentational skills (pertaining to textual, graphic and web-based promotional materials as appropriate)

Class

% Band

Descriptor

Marking Guidelines

Distinction

80–100

Exceptional

An outstanding recording which demonstrates meticulous and conscientious organisation at a high professional level; editing is of a high professional standard with an extremely mature, well balanced approach being evident throughout;

70–79

Excellent

An excellent recording which is extremely well prepared and demonstrates a wealth of high-quality learning at a professional level; editing is of very high standard;

Pass

60–69

Good

A good recording with an evident ability to prioritise, select and reject material in the editing process; promotional materials are generally succinct and distinctive;

50–59

Adequate

An adequate recording, which gives a clear sense of the learning experience of the individual; while of generally fair quality may be characterised by some naïve errors in the editing process;

Fail

40–49

Few Merits

While the recording shows some ability to reflect and edit, this is generally below an acceptable standard of submission;

0–39

Severely Limited

A severely limited recording which shows some basic editing skills but is marred by frequent errors of judgement; recording is well below an acceptable standard

Note: The guidelines may be used and interpreted:

  1. in relation to the relevant level of study, module aims, learning outcomes and the repertoire performed.
  2. in cases of disagreement between professional examiners; they are not intended to replace their expert judgments.
  3. to provide a framework for oral and/or written feedback to students to enhance and promote your subsequent learning and development.

Marking Guidelines: Self-evaluation and Evidence-based Portfolio

Criteria

  1. Ability to summarise, contextualise and organise materials
  2. Presentational skills (pertaining to textual, graphic and web-based promotional materials as appropriate)
  3. Powers of critical reflection

Class

% Band

Descriptor

Marking Guidelines

Distinction

80–100

Exceptional

An exceptional ability to organise, reflect upon and convey a wide range of high-quality learning experiences at a high professional level; promotional materials (if applicable) of a highly professional standard, expertly presented; a very mature and extremely well-balanced approach is evident throughout; submission is the best reflection of the outstanding attributes of the individual

70–79

Excellent

An extremely strong submission which is meticulously prepared and demonstrates a wealth of high-quality learning at a professional level; a mature reflection with admirable concision and intellectual acumen; a very good professional presentation of promotional materials (if applicable), underpinned by an outstanding range of learning experiences

Pass

60–69

Good

A good overall account of a broad range of learning experiences; materials are generally succinct and punchy; an evident an ability to prioritise, select and reject material; a very worthy reflective

account, well thought through and engaging; promotional materials (if applicable) are of a very good standard, imaginatively prepared

50–59

Adequate

Reasonably detailed accounting of the activities undertaken in the activity; a clear sense of the learning experience of the individual is evident; fair, if perhaps somewhat unsophisticated evaluation which may be characterised by some naïve solecisms; a reasonable range of reasonable experience is evident though the

reflection; promotional materials (if applicable) carefully prepared if somewhat uninspiring

Fail

40–49

Few Merits

Some record of learning experiences undertaken; some ability to reflect upon and evaluate these experiences objectively; perhaps a somewhat ramshackle and disorganised presentation although

it reveals a range of activity; promotional materials (if applicable) acceptable if a little unfocussed

0–39

Severely Limited

Although there may be some evidence of learning activity the materials lack focus and do not demonstrate any consistency; perhaps characterised by a mechanistic, unfocussed and essentially uncritical listing of learning which may seem rather insubstantial; promotional materials (if applicable) rather weak, with many errors

Note: The guidelines may be used and interpreted:

  1. in relation to the relevant level of study, module aims, learning outcomes and the repertoire performed.
  2. in cases of disagreement between professional examiners; they are not intended to replace their expert judgments.
  3. to provide a framework for oral and/or written feedback to students to enhance and promote your subsequent learning and development.

Marking Guidelines: Viva Voce

Criteria

  1. Powers of critical reflection
  2. Ability to communicate and field questions
  3. Presentational skills

Class

% Band

Descriptor

Marking Guidelines

Distinction

80–100

Exceptional

At a high professional level, an exceptional ability to communicate, with thoroughly detailed answers to questions posed; a very mature and extremely well- balanced approach is evident throughout with responses demonstrating outstanding insight into the topic(s) presented

70–79

Excellent

At a professional level, meticulously prepared with coherent and thoughtful answers to the questions posed; a mature reflection with admirable concision and intellectual acumen; excellent communication skills demonstrating clarity of thought

Pass

60–69

Good

Very good overall answers to the questions posed; an evident ability to evaluate and place the topic(s) presented in a broader context; engaging communication with the ability to express own viewpoint.

50–59

Adequate

Reasonably clear, if perhaps somewhat unsophisticated, answers to the questions posed; reasonable ability to communicate own viewpoint if in a somewhat uninspiring fashion

Fail

40–49

Few Merits

Some ability, albeit incomplete, to answer questions posed, and a somewhat disorganised approach in formulating responses; an inability to communicate either one’s own viewpoint or to summarise the views of others.

0–39

Severely Limited

Lacking clarity and signs of preparation; little or no ability to reflect upon and respond to the questions posed; evidence of a lack of ability to communicate own view point

Note: The guidelines may be used and interpreted:

  1. in relation to the relevant level of study, module aims, learning outcomes and the repertoire performed.
  2. in cases of disagreement between professional examiners; they are not intended to replace their expert judgments.
  3. to provide a framework for oral and/or written feedback to students to enhance and promote your subsequent learning and development

Marking Guidelines – Artistic Project

Outcome

Marking Guidelines

DISTINCTION PASS

The portfolio demonstrates excellent practical and/or creative skills in your Principal Study discipline commensurate with the expectations of the profession at a high level, and that you successfully contributed to internal or external performances and/or creative work. It demonstrates that you worked effectively, both independently and where appropriate as a member of a professional team. You understood at an excellent level the demands placed upon musicians in a timed performance/creative project environment and managed effective practice and time management.

In the viva you demonstrated an excellent ability to reflect on, and defend, a persuasive and extremely well written portfolio of the work undertaken throughout the project including its relevance for your future career aspirations.

PASS

The portfolio demonstrates practical and/or creative skills in your Principal Study discipline commensurate with the expectations of the profession, and that you successfully contributed to internal or external performances and/or creative work. It demonstrates that you worked effectively, both independently and where appropriate as a member of a professional team. You understood the demands placed upon musicians in a timed performance/creative project environment and managed effective practice and time management.

In the viva you reflected upon, and defended, a coherent portfolio of the work undertaken throughout the project including its relevance for your future career aspirations.

FAIL

The portfolio does not sufficiently demonstrate practical and/or creative skills in your Principal Study discipline commensurate with the expectations of the profession. It may be unclear, or not demonstrated, that you successfully contributed to internal or external performances and/or creative work. There is either no, or insufficient, information demonstrating that you worked effectively, both independently and where appropriate as a member of a professional team. You have not shown that you understood the demands placed upon musicians in a timed performance/creative project environment and managed effective practice and time management.

In the viva you did not reflect upon, or defend, a coherent portfolio of the work undertaken throughout the project including its relevance for your future career aspirations.

Note: The guidelines may be used and interpreted:

  1. in relation to the relevant Level of study, and the repertoire performed.
  2. in cases of disagreement between professional examiners; they are not intended to replace their expert judgments.
  3. to provide a framework for oral and/or written feedback to students to enhance and promote your subsequent learning and development.

Marking Guidelines – Presenting Research

Outcome

Marking Guidelines

DISTINCTION PASS

The portfolio demonstrates excellent scholarly insight and rigour commensurate with the expectations of the profession at a high level, successfully contributing to external or internal research events or related work. It further shows that you worked effectively both independently and where appropriate as a member of a professional team. You demonstrated an impressive understanding of the demands placed upon researchers given the timeframes and expectations of academic environments and managed work accordingly.

In the viva you demonstrated an excellent ability to reflect upon, and defend, a strongly persuasive portfolio of the work undertaken throughout the project including its relevance for your future career aspirations.

PASS

The portfolio demonstrates scholarly insight and rigour commensurate with the expectations of the profession, successfully contributing to external or internal research events or related work. It further shows that you

worked effectively both independently and where appropriate as a member of a professional team. You demonstrated an understanding of the demands placed upon researchers given the timeframes and expectations of academic environments and managed work accordingly.

In the viva you reflected upon, and defended, a coherent portfolio of the work undertaken throughout the project including its relevance for your future career aspirations.

FAIL

The portfolio does not sufficiently demonstrate scholarly insight and rigour commensurate with the expectations of the profession, successfully contributing to external or internal research events or related work. It does not show that you worked effectively both independently and where appropriate as a member of a professional team. You did not demonstrate an understanding of the demands placed upon researchers given the timeframes and expectations of academic environments and failed to manage work accordingly.

In the viva you failed to reflect upon, and defend, a coherent portfolio of the work undertaken throughout the project including its relevance for your future career aspirations.

Note: The guidelines may be used and interpreted:

  1. in relation to the relevant Level of study, and the repertoire performed.
  2. in cases of disagreement between professional examiners; they are not intended to replace their expert judgments.
  3. to provide a framework for oral and/or written feedback to students to enhance and promote your subsequent learning and development.